Thursday, October 8, 2009

"The Men We Carry In Our Minds" Response

I believe that situations like this does happen sometimes, there is an individual

that is very one sided and think about only their hardships and say that possibly

your wrong for something and not all the facts are looked at. I've had an experience

like this before, just being told to my face that I'm wrong about something or I

haven't gone through a difficult experience like they have and they're too closed

minded to listen to my defense and are too stubborn to accept any answer other than

their own and that is very annoying. This main character who has gone through some

many tough experiences when he was younger, I have not experienced many of the

things that he has. I haven't seen people working in fields and breaking back labor.

That's not to say that haven't seen any hard work, only not to that extent. I

haven't really had a conversation like this character has with another person on how

difficult life is for both sexes. I actually haven't really weighed the hardships of

both genders and thought who has it harder either. If I had known how hard people

work labor wise in fields then attended college I may be less naive on how fortunate

I am to be able to make more money in the future with less physical effort. The

character has realized that the way his fellow students were raised determined how

much they really take for granted now, and I've realized this pattern as well. I

can't really blame the people though. They haven't had the same experiences as I

have, so I cant exactly hold them to my standards. The author speaks of welfare and

this triggered in my brain that that is something I have never had to experience,

being very poor and barely being able to make it by. I have always lived somewhat

comfortably, been able to always have gifts for Christmas and Birthdays, so I have

a rather fortunate life style that this main character wouldn't be used to. So I can

only relate to this character on only a few levels.

3 comments:

  1. I think you made fairly good use of this essay to connect it to your own life. However, I found the response you gave to be a little bit too neutral to my liking. But, overall it was a pretty good response.

    ReplyDelete
  2. You definitely made an effort to connect the essay with your life. That was really great on your point; your ideas are really good. However, i think if you organized your ideas a little better, your point would come across a lot stronger. It seems like you kind of dance around what you are trying to say- really try to state the point really strong, and then support it with examples. Despite this, your response was good, and you definitely added some new insight to the essay. Nice work!

    ReplyDelete
  3. At first your response is a little confusing because I don't know what you're referring to, so just make sure you're clear. Also, I think that just because you haven't gone through a similar situation that you can't form some kind of understanding or opinion about the topic or if you couldn't that should be a apart of your response to critique Sanders writting.

    ReplyDelete